Veterans Committee Data

2024

Contemporary Baseball Era (Non-Players)

Player Category Votes Total Pct
Jim Leyland Manager 15 16 93.8%
Lou Piniella Manager 11 16 68.8%
Bill White Executive 10 16 62.5%
Joe West Umpire <5 16
Hank Peters Executive <5 16
Ed Montague Umpire <5 16
Cito Gaston Manager <5 16
Davey Johnson Manager <5 16

2023

Contemporary Baseball Era (Players)

Player Category Votes Total Pct
Fred McGriff Player 16 16 100.0%
Don Mattingly Player 8 16 50.0%
Curt Schilling Player 7 16 43.8%
Dale Murphy Player 6 16 37.5%
Rafael Palmeiro Player <4 16
Roger Clemens Player <4 16
Albert Belle Player <4 16
Barry Bonds Player <4 16

2022

Early Baseball Era

Player Category Votes Total Pct
Buck O’Neil Pioneer 13 16 81.3%
Bud Fowler Pioneer 12 16 75.0%
Vic Harris Player 10 16 62.5%
John Donaldson Player 8 16 50.0%
Allie Reynolds Player 6 16 37.5%
Lefty O'Doul Player 5 16 31.3%
George Scales Player 4 16 25.0%
Dick Redding Player <4 16
Bill Dahlen Player <4 16
Grant Johnson Player <4 16

Golden Days Era

Player Category Votes Total Pct
Minnie Miñoso Player 14 16 87.5%
Jim Kaat Player 12 16 75.0%
Gil Hodges Player 12 16 75.0%
Tony Oliva Player 12 16 75.0%
Dick Allen Player 11 16 68.8%
Roger Maris Player <4 16
Danny Murtaugh Manager <4 16
Maury Wills Player <4 16
Ken Boyer Player <4 16
Billy Pierce Player <4 16

2021

The Era Committees did not meet becuase of the COVID-19 pandemic.

2020

Modern Baseball Era

Player Category Votes Total Pct
Ted Simmons Player 13 16 81.3%
Marvin Miller Executive 13 16 81.3%
Dwight Evans Player 8 16 50.0%
Dave Parker Player 7 16 43.8%
Steve Garvey Player 6 16 37.5%
Lou Whitaker Player 6 16 37.5%
Don Mattingly Player <4 16
Thurman Munson Player <4 16
Dale Murphy Player <4 16
Tommy John Player <4 16

2019

Today’s Game Era

Player Category Votes Total Pct
Lee Smith Player 16 16 100.0%
Harold Baines Player 12 16 75.0%
Lou Piniella Manager 11 16 68.8%
Orel Hershiser Player <5 16
Will Clark Player <5 16
Albert Belle Player <5 16
Charlie Manuel Manager <5 16
Davey Johnson Manager <5 16
Joe Carter Player <5 16
George Steinbrenner Executive <5 16

2018

Modern Baseball Era

Player Category Votes Total Pct
Jack Morris Player 14 16 87.5%
Alan Trammell Player 13 16 81.3%
Ted Simmons Player 11 16 68.8%
Marvin Miller Executive 7 16 43.8%
Don Mattingly Player <7 16
Dave Parker Player <7 16
Steve Garvey Player <7 16
Tommy John Player <7 16
Dale Murphy Player <7 16
Luis Tiant Player <7 16

2017

Today’s Game Era

Player Category Votes Total Pct
John Schuerholz Executive 16 16 100.0%
Bud Selig Executive 16 16 100.0%
Lou Piniella Manager 7 16 43.8%
Orel Hershiser Player <5 16
Harold Baines Player <5 16
Will Clark Player <5 16
Albert Belle Player <5 16
Mark McGwire Player <5 16
Davey Johnson Manager <5 16
George Steinbrenner Executive <5 16

2016

Pre-Integration Era

Player Category Votes Total Pct
Doc Adams Pioneer 10 16 62.5%
Harry Stovey Player 8 16 50.0%
Bill Dahlen Player 8 16 50.0%
Frank McCormick Player <4 16
Marty Marion Player <4 16
Garry Hermann Executive <4 16
Chris Von der Ahe Executive <4 16
Bucky Walters Player <4 16
Sam Breadon Executive <4 16
Wes Ferrell Player <4 16

2015

Golden Era

Player Category Votes Total Pct
Dick Allen Player 11 16 68.8%
Tony Oliva Player 11 16 68.8%
Jim Kaat Player 10 16 62.5%
Maury Wills Player 9 16 56.3%
Minnie Miñoso Player 8 16 50.0%
Gil Hodges Player <4 16
Bob Howsam Executive <4 16
Ken Boyer Player <4 16
Billy Pierce Player <4 16
Luis Tiant Player <4 16

2014

Expansion Era

Player Category Votes Total Pct
Bobby Cox Manager 16 16 100.0%
Tony La Russa Manager 16 16 100.0%
Joe Torre Manager 16 16 100.0%
Marvin Miller Executive <7 16
Dave Parker Player <7 16
Dave Concepcion Player <7 16
Ted Simmons Player <7 16
Steve Garvey Player <7 16
Dan Quisenberry Player <7 16
Tommy John Player <7 16
Billy Martin Manager <7 16
George Steinbrenner Executive <7 16

2013

Pre-Integration Era

Player Category Votes Total Pct
Hank O'Day Umpire 15 16 93.8%
Jacob Ruppert Executive 15 16 93.8%
Deacon White Player 14 16 87.5%
Bill Dahlen Player 10 16 62.5%
Tony Mullane Player <3 16
Al Reach Pioneer <3 16
Marty Marion Player <3 16
Bucky Walters Player <3 16
Sam Breadon Executive <3 16
Wes Ferrell Player <3 16

2012

Golden Era

Player Category Votes Total Pct
Ron Santo Player 15 16 93.8%
Jim Kaat Player 10 16 62.5%
Minnie Miñoso Player 9 16 56.3%
Gil Hodges Player 9 16 56.3%
Tony Oliva Player 8 16 50.0%
Allie Reynolds Player <3 16
Ken Boyer Player <3 16
Charlie Finley Executive <3 16
Luis Tiant Player <3 16
Buzzie Bavasi Executive <3 16

2011

Expansion Era

Player Category Votes Total Pct
Pat Gillick Executive 13 16 81.3%
Marvin Miller Executive 11 16 68.8%
Dave Concepcion Player 8 16 50.0%
Al Oliver Player <8 16
Tommy John Player <8 16
Ted Simmons Player <8 16
Steve Garvey Player <8 16
Vida Blue Player <8 16
Rusty Staub Player <8 16
Ron Guidry Player <8 16
George Steinbrenner Executive <8 16
Billy Martin Manager <8 16

2010

Managers/Umpires

Player Category Votes Total Pct
Doug Harvey Umpire 15 16 93.8%
Whitey Herzog Manager 14 16 87.5%
Danny Murtaugh Manager 8 16 50.0%
Hank O'Day Umpire 8 16 50.0%
Gene Mauch Manager <3 16
Tom Kelly Manager <3 16
Steve O'Neill Manager <3 16
Davey Johnson Manager <3 16
Billy Martin Manager <3 16

Executives/Pioneers

Player Category Votes Total Pct
John Fetzer Executive 8 12 66.7%
Jacob Ruppert Executive 7 12 58.3%
Marvin Miller Executive 7 12 58.3%
Ewing Kauffman Executive 6 12 50.0%
Charlie Grimm Manager 3 12 25.0%
Gabe Paul Executive <3 12
Bob Howsam Executive <3 12
Gene Autry Executive <3 12
Bill White Executive <3 12
John McHale Executive <3 12
Sam Breadon Executive <3 12

2009

1943 and Later

Player Category Votes Total Pct
Ron Santo Player 39 64 60.9%
Jim Kaat Player 38 64 59.4%
Tony Oliva Player 33 64 51.6%
Gil Hodges Player 28 64 43.8%
Joe Torre Manager 19 64 29.7%
Maury Wills Player 15 64 23.4%
Luis Tiant Player 13 64 20.3%
Vada Pinson Player 12 64 18.8%
Al Oliver Player 9 64 14.1%
Dick Allen Player 7 64 10.9%

The following players appeared on the Historical Overview Committee’s preliminary list of players but did not appear on the final 1943 and Later ballot • Ken Boyer • Bert Campaneris • Rocky Colavito • Mike Cuellar • Steve Garvey • Ted Kluszewski • Mickey Lolich • Roger Maris • Lee May • Minnie Miñoso • Thurman Munson

Pre-1943

Player Category Votes Total Pct
Joe Gordon Player 10 12 83.3%
Allie Reynolds Player 8 12 66.7%
Wes Ferrell Player 6 12 50.0%
Deacon White Player 5 12 41.7%
Mickey Vernon Player 5 12 41.7%
Bucky Walters Player 4 12 33.3%
Sherry Magee Player 3 12 25.0%
Carl Mays Player <3 12
Bill Dahlen Player <3 12
Vern Stephens Player <3 12

2008

Managers/Umpires

Player Category Votes Total Pct
Dick Williams Manager 13 16 81.3%
Billy Southworth Manager 13 16 81.3%
Whitey Herzog Manager 11 16 68.8%
Doug Harvey Umpire 11 16 68.8%
Danny Murtaugh Manager 6 16 37.5%
Hank O'Day Umpire 4 16 25.0%
Gene Mauch Manager <3 16
Davey Johnson Manager <3 16
Billy Martin Manager <3 16
Cy Rigler Umpire <3 16

Executives/Pioneers

Player Category Votes Total Pct
Bowie Kuhn Executive 10 12 83.3%
Barney Dreyfuss Executive 10 12 83.3%
Walter O'Malley Executive 9 12 75.0%
Ewing Kauffman Executive 5 12 41.7%
John Fetzer Executive 4 12 33.3%
Marvin Miller Executive 3 12 25.0%
Bob Howsam Executive 3 12 25.0%
Gabe Paul Executive <3 12
John McHale Executive <3 12
Buzzie Bavasi Executive <3 12

2007

Players

Player Category Votes Total Pct
Ron Santo Player 57 82 69.5%
Jim Kaat Player 52 82 63.4%
Gil Hodges Player 50 82 61.0%
Tony Oliva Player 47 82 57.3%
Maury Wills Player 33 82 40.2%
Joe Torre Manager 26 82 31.7%
Don Newcombe Player 17 82 20.7%
Vada Pinson Player 16 82 19.5%
Roger Maris Player 15 82 18.3%
Lefty O'Doul Player 15 82 18.3%
Luis Tiant Player 15 82 18.3%
Al Oliver Player 14 82 17.1%
Curt Flood Player 14 82 17.1%
Mickey Vernon Player 14 82 17.1%
Cecil Travis Player 12 82 14.6%
Minnie Miñoso Player 12 82 14.6%
Marty Marion Player 11 82 13.4%
Dick Allen Player 11 82 13.4%
Joe Gordon Player 10 82 12.2%
Ken Boyer Player 9 82 11.0%
Mickey Lolich Player 8 82 9.8%
Wes Ferrell Player 7 82 8.5%
Carl Mays Player 6 82 7.3%
Sparky Lyle Player 6 82 7.3%
Thurman Munson Player 6 82 7.3%
Rocky Colavito Player 5 82 6.1%
Bobby Bonds Player 1 82 1.2%

The following players appeared on the Historical Overview Committee’s preliminary list of 200 players but did not appear on the final ballot • Babe Adams • Joe Adcock • Felipe Alou • Sal Bando • Dick Bartell • Ginger Beaumont • Mark Belanger • Wally Berger • Larry Bowa • Harry Brecheen • Tommy Bridges • Pete Browning • Charlie Buffinton • Lew Burdette • George J. Burns • George H. Burns • Dolph Camilli • Bert Campaneris • Bob Caruthers • George Case • Norm Cash • Phil Cavarretta • Spud Chandler • Ben Chapman • Mort Cooper • Walker Cooper • Wilbur Cooper • Doc Cramer • Del Crandall • Gavvy Cravath • Lave Cross • Mike Cuellar • Bill Dahlen • Alvin Dark • Jake Daubert • Tommy Davis • Willie Davis • Paul Derringer • Dom DiMaggio • Patsy Donovan • Larry Doyle • Jimmie Dykes • Bob Elliott • Del Ennis • Carl Erskine • Roy Face • Fred Fitzsimmons • Bill Freehan • Jim Fregosi • Carl Furillo • Mike Garcia • Jim Gilliam • Jack Glasscock • Dick Groat • Heinie Groh • Stan Hack • Mel Harder • Jeff Heath • Tommy Henrich • Babe Herman • John Hiller • Ken Holtzman • Burt Hooton • Willie Horton • Elston Howard • Frank Howard • Billy Hoy • Larry Jackson • Jackie Jensen • Sam Jethroe • Bob Johnson • Joe Judge • Ken Keltner • Don Kessinger • Johnny Kling • Ted Kluszewski • Jerry Koosman • Ray Kremer • Harvey Kuenn • Sam Leever • Sherm Lollar • Eddie Lopat • Dolf Luque • Greg Luzinski • Sherry Magee • Sal Maglie • Jim Maloney • Firpo Marberry • Mike Marshall • Pepper Martin • Lee May • Tim McCarver • Frank McCormick • Lindy McDaniel • Gil McDougald • Sam McDowell • Tug McGraw • Stuffy McInnis • Denny McLain • Roy McMillan • Dave McNally • Andy Messersmith • Bob Meusel • Irish Meusel • Clyde Milan • Bing Miller • Stu Miller • Terry Moore • Tony Mullane • Bobby Murcer • Johnny Murphy • Buddy Myer • Art Nehf • Claude Osteen • Amos Otis • Andy Pafko • Milt Pappas • Camilo Pascual • Ron Perranoski • Jim Perry • Johnny Pesky • Rico Petrocelli • Deacon Phillippe • Billy Pierce • Johnny Podres • Boog Powell • Jack Quinn • Vic Raschi • Ed Reulbach • Allie Reynolds • Mickey Rivers • Steve Rogers • Eddie Rommel • Charlie Root • Al Rosen • Schoolboy Rowe • Jimmy Ryan • Johnny Sain • Slim Sallee • Wally Schang • George Scott • Rip Sewell • Bob Shawkey • Urban Shocker • Roy Sievers • Curt Simmons • Ken Singleton • Reggie Smith • Rusty Staub • Riggs Stephenson • Vern Stephens • Mel Stottlemyre • Harry Stovey • Jesse Tannehill • Fred Tenney • Bobby Thomson • Mike Tiernan • Hal Trosky • Virgil Trucks • Johnny Vander Meer • George Van Haltren • Bobby Veach • Dixie Walker • Bucky Walters • Lon Warneke • Bob Watson • Will White • Cy Williams • Ken Williams • Smoky Joe Wood • Wilbur Wood • Jimmy Wynn • Rudy York

Composite

Player Category Votes Total Pct
Doug Harvey Umpire 52 82 63.4%
Marvin Miller Executive 51 82 62.2%
Walter O'Malley Executive 36 82 43.9%
Buzzie Bavasi Executive 30 82 36.6%
Dick Williams Manager 30 82 36.6%
Whitey Herzog Manager 29 82 35.4%
Bill White Executive 24 82 29.3%
Bowie Kuhn Executive 14 82 17.1%
August Busch Executive 13 82 15.9%
Billy Martin Manager 12 82 14.6%
Paul Richards Manager 10 82 12.2%
Charlie Finley Executive 10 82 12.2%
Gabe Paul Executive 10 82 12.2%
Phil Wrigley Executive 9 82 11.0%
Harry Dalton Executive 8 82 9.8%

The following candidates appeared on the Historical Overview Committee’s preliminary list of 200 managers, umpires, and executives but did not appear on the final ballot • Gene Autry • Sam Breadon • Charles Bronfman • George W. Bush • Bing Devine • Chub Feeney • John Fetzer • Calvin Griffith • Garry Hermann • John Heydler • Bob Howsam • Ewing Kauffman • Frank Lane • John McSherry • Paul Owens • Steve Palermo • Bob Quinn • Beans Reardon • Cy Rigler • Ben Shibe • Charles Somers • Bill Summers • Lee Weyer • Roger Craig • Bill Dinneen • Chuck Dressen • Barney Dreyfuss • Charlie Grimm • Ralph Houk • Fred Hutchinson • Davey Johnson • Gene Mauch • Jack McKeon • Danny Murtaugh • Hank O'Day • Steve O'Neill • Babe Pinelli • Al Reach • Bill Rigney • Jacob Ruppert • Billy Southworth • Chuck Tanner • Birdie Tebbetts • Chris Von der Ahe • Don Zimmer

2006

No election.

2005

Players

Player Category Votes Total Pct
Gil Hodges Player 52 80 65.0%
Ron Santo Player 52 80 65.0%
Tony Oliva Player 45 80 56.3%
Jim Kaat Player 43 80 53.8%
Joe Torre Manager 36 80 45.0%
Maury Wills Player 26 80 32.5%
Vada Pinson Player 23 80 28.8%
Luis Tiant Player 20 80 25.0%
Roger Maris Player 19 80 23.8%
Marty Marion Player 16 80 20.0%
Ken Boyer Player 15 80 18.8%
Joe Gordon Player 14 80 17.5%
Carl Mays Player 12 80 15.0%
Dick Allen Player 12 80 15.0%
Minnie Miñoso Player 12 80 15.0%
Curt Flood Player 10 80 12.5%
Wes Ferrell Player 9 80 11.3%
Mickey Lolich Player 9 80 11.3%
Don Newcombe Player 8 80 10.0%
Sparky Lyle Player 7 80 8.8%
Elston Howard Player 6 80 7.5%
Rocky Colavito Player 4 80 5.0%
Bobby Bonds Player 4 80 5.0%
Thurman Munson Player 2 80 2.5%
Smoky Joe Wood Player 2 80 2.5%

The following players appeared on the Historical Overview Committee’s preliminary list of 200 players but did not appear on the final ballot • Babe Adams • Joe Adcock • Felipe Alou • Sal Bando • Dick Bartell • Ginger Beaumont • Mark Belanger • Wally Berger • Harry Brecheen • Tommy Bridges • Pete Browning • Charlie Buffinton • Lew Burdette • George J. Burns • George H. Burns • Dolph Camilli • Bert Campaneris • Bob Caruthers • George Case • Norm Cash • Phil Cavarretta • Spud Chandler • Ben Chapman • Mort Cooper • Walker Cooper • Wilbur Cooper • Doc Cramer • Del Crandall • Gavvy Cravath • Lave Cross • Mike Cuellar • Bill Dahlen • Alvin Dark • Jake Daubert • Tommy Davis • Willie Davis • Paul Derringer • Dom DiMaggio • Patsy Donovan • Larry Doyle • Jimmie Dykes • Bob Elliott • Del Ennis • Carl Erskine • Roy Face • Fred Fitzsimmons • Bill Freehan • Jim Fregosi • Carl Furillo • Mike Garcia • Jim Gilliam • Jack Glasscock • Charlie Grimm • Dick Groat • Heinie Groh • Stan Hack • Harvey Haddix • Mel Harder • Jeff Heath • Tommy Henrich • Babe Herman • Pinky Higgins • John Hiller • Ken Holtzman • Willie Horton • Frank Howard • Billy Hoy • Larry Jackson • Jackie Jensen • Sam Jethroe • Bob Johnson • Davey Johnson • Joe Judge • Willie Kamm • Ken Keltner • Don Kessinger • Johnny Kling • Ted Kluszewski • Ray Kremer • Harvey Kuenn • Joe Kuhel • Vern Law • Sam Leever • Sherm Lollar • Herman Long • Eddie Lopat • Dolf Luque • Sal Maglie • Jim Maloney • Firpo Marberry • Mike Marshall • Pepper Martin • Lee May • Tim McCarver • Frank McCormick • Lindy McDaniel • Gil McDougald • Sam McDowell • Stuffy McInnis • Denny McLain • Roy McMillan • Dave McNally • Andy Messersmith • Bob Meusel • Irish Meusel • Bing Miller • Stu Miller • Terry Moore • Tony Mullane • Bobby Murcer • Johnny Murphy • Buddy Myer • Art Nehf • Bobo Newsom • Lefty O'Doul • Claude Osteen • Andy Pafko • Milt Pappas • Camilo Pascual • Ron Perranoski • Jim Perry • Johnny Pesky • Rico Petrocelli • Deacon Phillippe • Billy Pierce • Wally Pipp • Johnny Podres • Boog Powell • Jack Quinn • Vic Raschi • Ed Reulbach • Allie Reynolds • Eddie Rommel • Charlie Root • Al Rosen • Schoolboy Rowe • Pete Runnels • Jimmy Ryan • Johnny Sain • Hank Sauer • Wally Schang • George Scott • Rip Sewell • Bob Shawkey • Urban Shocker • Roy Sievers • Curt Simmons • Reggie Smith • Riggs Stephenson • Vern Stephens • Mel Stottlemyre • Harry Stovey • Jesse Tannehill • Tony Taylor • Johnny Temple • Fred Tenney • Bobby Thomson • Mike Tiernan • Cecil Travis • Hal Trosky • Virgil Trucks • Johnny Vander Meer • George Van Haltren • Bobby Veach • Mickey Vernon • Dixie Walker • Bucky Walters • Lon Warneke • Will White • Cy Williams • Ken Williams • Wilbur Wood • Glenn Wright • Jimmy Wynn • Rudy York

2004

No election.

2003

Players

Player Category Votes Total Pct
Gil Hodges Player 50 81 61.7%
Tony Oliva Player 48 81 59.3%
Ron Santo Player 46 81 56.8%
Joe Torre Manager 29 81 35.8%
Maury Wills Player 24 81 29.6%
Vada Pinson Player 21 81 25.9%
Joe Gordon Player 19 81 23.5%
Roger Maris Player 18 81 22.2%
Marty Marion Player 17 81 21.0%
Minnie Miñoso Player 16 81 19.8%
Carl Mays Player 16 81 19.8%
Allie Reynolds Player 16 81 19.8%
Mickey Lolich Player 13 81 16.0%
Dick Allen Player 13 81 16.0%
Wes Ferrell Player 12 81 14.8%
Ken Boyer Player 11 81 13.6%
Don Newcombe Player 11 81 13.6%
Curt Flood Player 10 81 12.3%
Ken Williams Player 8 81 9.9%
Rocky Colavito Player 7 81 8.6%
Elston Howard Player 6 81 7.4%
Bob Meusel Player 6 81 7.4%
Bobby Bonds Player 5 81 6.2%
Thurman Munson Player 4 81 4.9%
Ted Kluszewski Player 4 81 4.9%
Mike Marshall Player 3 81 3.7%

The following players appeared on the Historical Overview Committee’s preliminary list of 200 players but did not appear on the final ballot • Babe Adams • Joe Adcock • Johnny Allen • Felipe Alou • Bobby Avila • Sal Bando • Dick Bartell • Ginger Beaumont • Glenn Beckert • Wally Berger • Harry Brecheen • Tommy Bridges • Pete Browning • Charlie Buffinton • Lew Burdette • George J. Burns • George H. Burns • Guy Bush • Dolph Camilli • Leo Cardenas • Bob Caruthers • George Case • Norm Cash • Phil Cavarretta • Spud Chandler • Ben Chapman • Mort Cooper • Walker Cooper • Wilbur Cooper • Doc Cramer • Del Crandall • Gavvy Cravath • Lave Cross • Mike Cuellar • Bill Dahlen • Alvin Dark • Jake Daubert • Tommy Davis • Willie Davis • Paul Derringer • Dom DiMaggio • Patsy Donovan • Jimmie Dykes • Bob Elliott • Del Ennis • Carl Erskine • Roy Face • Fred Fitzsimmons • Bill Freehan • Jim Fregosi • Larry French • Carl Furillo • Mike Garcia • Jim Gilliam • Jack Glasscock • Charlie Grimm • Dick Groat • Heinie Groh • Stan Hack • Harvey Haddix • Mel Harder • Jeff Heath • Tommy Henrich • Babe Herman • Pinky Higgins • John Hiller • Ken Holtzman • Willie Horton • Frank Howard • Billy Hoy • Larry Jackson • Julian Javier • Jackie Jensen • Sam Jethroe • Bob Johnson • Davey Johnson • Joe Judge • Willie Kamm • Ken Keltner • Don Kessinger • Johnny Kling • Ray Kremer • Harvey Kuenn • Joe Kuhel • Vern Law • Sam Leever • Sherm Lollar • Herman Long • Eddie Lopat • Dolf Luque • Sal Maglie • Jim Maloney • Firpo Marberry • Pepper Martin • Tim McCarver • Frank McCormick • Lindy McDaniel • Gil McDougald • Sam McDowell • Stuffy McInnis • Denny McLain • Roy McMillan • Dave McNally • Andy Messersmith • Irish Meusel • Bing Miller • Stu Miller • Terry Moore • Tony Mullane • Johnny Murphy • Buddy Myer • Art Nehf • Bobo Newsom • Lefty O'Doul • Claude Osteen • Milt Pappas • Mel Parnell • Camilo Pascual • Ron Perranoski • Jim Perry • Johnny Pesky • Rico Petrocelli • Deacon Phillippe • Billy Pierce • Wally Pipp • Johnny Podres • Boog Powell • Jack Quinn • Vic Raschi • Ed Reulbach • J.R. Richard • Eddie Rommel • Charlie Root • Al Rosen • Schoolboy Rowe • Pete Runnels • Jimmy Ryan • Johnny Sain • Manny Sanguillen • Hank Sauer • Wally Schang • Hal Schumacher • George Scott • Rip Sewell • Bob Shawkey • Urban Shocker • Roy Sievers • Curt Simmons • Riggs Stephenson • Vern Stephens • Mel Stottlemyre • Harry Stovey • Jesse Tannehill • Tony Taylor • Johnny Temple • Fred Tenney • Bobby Thomson • Mike Tiernan • Cecil Travis • Hal Trosky • Virgil Trucks • Johnny Vander Meer • George Van Haltren • Bobby Veach • Mickey Vernon • Dixie Walker • Bucky Walters • Lon Warneke • Will White • Cy Williams • Wilbur Wood • Glenn Wright • Jimmy Wynn • Rudy York

Composite

Player Category Votes Total Pct
Doug Harvey Umpire 48 79 60.8%
Walter O'Malley Executive 38 79 48.1%
Marvin Miller Executive 35 79 44.3%
Buzzie Bavasi Executive 34 79 43.0%
Dick Williams Manager 33 79 41.8%
Whitey Herzog Manager 25 79 31.6%
Bill White Executive 22 79 27.8%
Billy Martin Manager 22 79 27.8%
Bowie Kuhn Executive 20 79 25.3%
Gabe Paul Executive 13 79 16.5%
August Busch Executive 11 79 13.9%
Paul Richards Manager 10 79 12.7%
Charlie Finley Executive 9 79 11.4%